Check out PD Article on Maryland's Funding of Public Education

The Cleveland Plain Dealer has an article in the Monday, May 28, 2007, edition about how Maryland funds public education. Maryland's approach to school funding is a model for the approach being taken by groups which are supporting an Ohio ballot initiative this fall. The approach is described in the article as follows:

The Ohio amendment would charge the State Board of Education with deciding the components and cost of a high-quality education. The legislature and the governor then would be required to find a way to pay for it.

In contrast, Ohio now sets aside an amount of money for schools based on available revenue rather than determining what is needed. The state share is combined with a local share that mostly comes from property taxes. It's a system in which districts with eroding tax bases can be left in the lurch. Even districts in affluent communities are forced to ask voters to raise property taxes every few years to maintain their funding levels.

One thing that Ohio has lacked, according to the proponents of this plan, is any idea on how much a child's education should cost. Given the fact that Ohio now requires students to pass proficiency tests to graduate, and given the fact that the material those tests cover is state mandated, it shouldn't be hard for the state to figure out what would be the cost of providing an education to make sure a child learns the mandated material. So far, though, Ohio's state government has rejected such an approach.

What's interesting about Ohio's approach is that the state government under Republican rule has had no hesitation in telling local school districts what material they should teach. Nor has the General Assembly had any problems with telling children that if they don't learn what the state believes they should learn, then they can't graduate. The state has, however, hesitated in telling educators, parents, and children what the cost is per child of providing an education that will allow children to meet state-required proficiency standards.

Here is the bottom line: if the state is going to require a certain level of proficiency from its students before they can get a diploma, then it is only fair that the state make sure that each child's school district have the resources to provide that level of education. It is impossible for parents to know whether the state is providing such resources unless they know the cost of such resources. No matter what solution is found for funding education in Ohio, the first step should be ascertaining the cost of providing an education to allow children to meet the state's proficiency standards. If Maryland can do it, why can't Ohio?

Cross-posted at www.medinacountycommonsense.com

Will Medina County Start a Trend in Passing Sales Taxes for Schools?

Terry Oblander of the Cleveland Plain Dealer has an article in this Sunday's edition in which he raises the question of whether Medina County will start a trend of counties enacting sales tax increases to fund schools. The article suggests that it probably won't happen, although it is possible that the county commissioners' organization will seek legislation to raise the amount of money counties can collect in sales taxes.

Right now counties can collect up to 1.5% on top of what the state charges. What Medina County did was to pass a sales tax for capital improvements with the understanding that only schools will benefit from the sales tax. There are legal questions as to whether you can require that a county capital improvements board just fund school projects with the funds.

Right now, this problem won't come up because the people appointed to the new Medina County board are pledged to use the money just for school projects. The question remains, though, whether future county commissioners will only appoint such members. The thinking is that they will, but thre is no legal requirement that they do so.

The article also points out that Medina County has shopping districts that bring in residents from other counties. One selling point was that other counties' residents will be helping fund Medina County's schools. Since we live in Medina County we are all for that, but how many counties can effectively make that argument?

Oblander's bottom line seems to be that while this tax increase is good for Medina County, and could lead to lower property taxes in Medina County, it is not likely to be adopted by a lot of other counties.

A Reader's Letter to Governor Ted Strickland on Vouchers

Views expressed in reader submissions do not necessarily reflect the views of MCDAC or its officers.

May 1, 2007

The Honorable Ted Strickland
Governor
Riffe Center, 30th Floor77 South High StreetColumbus, OH 43215-6108

Dear Governor Strickland:

I cannot begin to tell you the depth of my despair on learning that you are considering abandoning what we thought was your promise to begin the undoing of the damage caused by school vouchers in our state.

Sixteen years of Republican control of our state government has nearly gutted public education. As one who was the recipient of the benefit of the leveling of the playing field provided by public education, I am appalled with the scheme now in place. When I am out of state discussing schools, I am ashamed to say where I live.

I dare say that most citizens in Ohio do not know the breadth of impact of vouchers. Indeed, until today, I did not know that our own Department of Education has been giving power point presentations using high pressure sales techniques to encourage parents to abandon public schools by giving out $4,000-$5,000 per year scholarships for their children to attend private schools. This is taxpayer money--taken from the local school districts that are in most need of support.

If you must give vouchers to our children, give them ONLY to those children who are failing—the truants, the unmotivated, the very ones who might succeed with special attention.

Governor, don’t abandon us in the political malaise that we call politics. Make us proud to live in Ohio again.

Billie Brandon
School Board Member
Mid-Ohio Educational Services Center
Pioneer Career and Technology Center